The tragic uprooting and collapse of a banyan tree July 12 on Kilauea Avenue that killed two woman has Hilo’s state senator concerned that something similar could occur with one or more of the historic trees along Banyan Drive on Hilo’s Waiakea Peninsula.

While announcing the release by Gov. Josh Green of $1 million in general obligation bond funds to help with master planning for the redevelopment of the Waiakea Peninsula, Sen. Lorraine Inouye told the Tribune-Herald the massive “banyan trees have been neglected I don’t know how many years.”

“In my disappointment with what’s happening on Banyan Drive, I’ve worked hard to acquire and get some money to start working on Uncle Billy’s,” said Inouye, a Democrat, referring to a just over half-acre site that is now empty after the decrepit former Uncle Billy’s Hilo Bay Hotel was demolished last year. “And I know the county was responsible for the maintenance of the banyan trees and the easement on Banyan Drive.”

The Uncle Billy’s site and the recently-shuttered Country Club Condominium Hotel — as well as the Hilo Hawaiian, Grand Naniloa and Hilo Reeds Bay hotels, the nine-hole Naniloa Golf Course and the Bayview Banyan Apartments — are part of approximately 101 acres of state land on and around the Waiakea Peninsula managed by the Department of Land and Natural Resources.

DLNR said in an email that, according to its Land Division staff, “most of the banyan trees along Banyan Drive are in the county right-of-way.”

“There may be some trees that are on state-leased land, but none are maintained by the department,” the email stated. “Additionally, staff has been in contact with Sen. Inouye and county (Department of Public Works) regarding these trees.”

Tom Callis, spokesman for Mayor Kimo Alameda, said the county’s Department of Parks and Recreation “manages and maintains banyan trees located at Lili‘uokalani Gardens and Reeds Bay Beach Park” on the peninsula.

“If trees growing over Banyan Drive create a road safety issue, the Department of Public Works conducts the necessary pruning over the roadway,” Callis said. “Because of the importance of these trees to the community and our interest in protecting public safety, we are engaging with the Department of Land and Natural Resources to address jurisdictional and ownership questions for banyans located along or near Banyan Drive.”

The $1 million in bond funding was released as seed money for the peninsula’s redevelopment, despite the failure this legislative session of Senate Bill 1078, introduced by Inouye, and House Bill 818, introduced by Hilo Rep. Sue Keohokapu-Lee Loy.

Those measures — which Inouye told the Hawaii Island Chamber of Commerce in late May failed because of statutory flaws — were intended to establish the “Waiakea Peninsula Community Development District,” set up a special fund for that district, and create up a nine-member board to manage the area. To do that, the bills stipulated the peninsula’s lands would be transferred from the DLNR to the Hawaii Community Development Authority. That would include lands under DLNR leases, an action prohibited under Hawaii Revised Statutes 171-6.

“I’m grateful to the governor for releasing these funds to begin planning this major project and to support the first phase of development at the Waiakea Peninsula,” Inouye said. “With the continued support of our state and county partners, I look forward to seeing this vision take shape.”

The revitalization of Banyan Drive has been a hot-button topic for at least the past decade, despite much of the peninsula falling into visible disrepair, with the Country Club now fenced off and awaiting an as-yet-unfunded demolition. A 2018 estimate placed implosion of the decrepit six-story building at $6.2 million. The actual price tag will undoubtedly be much higher when and if said demolition takes place.

“Banyan trees on Banyan Drive are very concerning to me because we’ve never had the tree canopies on Banyan Drive meeting each other. And I’m trying to remember the last time the county took responsibility,” Inouye said. “There are roots that are coming down from the trees that should not happen. There’s now a lot of overgrowth.”

She also said the name plates bearing the names of the people who planted the banyans “have been neglected.”

According to Callis, park safety and tree maintenance have been priorities for Parks and Recreation under Alameda.

“Trees at Lili‘uokalani Gardens were recently inspected as part of tree maintenance/safety efforts that are ongoing,” he said. “Recently, maintenance division district supervisors at the Department of Parks and Recreation were asked to identify trees of concern at county park facilities that could require additional action.

“This was requested before the banyan tree on state land fell. That assessment is ongoing.”

Callis said the county, which installed name plates with the names and dates of notables who planted the signature banyans “is looking at replacing/upgrading them.”

A short list, by no means complete, of prominent people who planted banyans on the semi-circular drive include: Princess Abigail Kawananakoa; then-President Franklin Delano Roosevelt; U.S. Sen. Richard Nixon, prior to his presidency; music legend Louis “Satchmo” Armstrong; baseball slugger George Herman “Babe” Ruth; aviator Amelia Earhart; filmmaker Cecil B. DeMille; and actor and conservationist Leo Carillo.

The Banyan Drive banyans, unlike the Kilauea Avenue banyan that fell, are not designated as “exceptional trees” by the county, although they have been nominated. The exceptional tree designation is intended to safeguard historic trees from land development.

That nomination was considered and shelved during a meeting of the county’s Arborist Advisory Committee on March 27, 2024. The deferral was requested by Gordon Heit, the district land agent for DLNR’s Land Division, who asked for additional location and jurisdiction clarification for the 49 trees along the route, as well as discussions with stakeholders about the area’s redevelopment.

As for the Kilauea Avenue banyan, the DLNR said Friday it has hired a contractor to remove the tree from where it fell, and work is scheduled to start Tuesday.

DLNR said the fallen tree “was at least partially on DLNR land, and our records show regular maintenance on the tree dating back to at least 2006, with the most recent service in 2021.”

“In every instance, the tree maintenance was performed by a licensed contractor with certified arborists,” DLNR said.